RIO DE JANEIRO (AP) 鈥� A Brazilian Supreme Court panel on Monday unanimously upheld the decision of one of its justices to nationwide, according to the court鈥檚 website.
The broader support among justices undermines the effort by Musk and his supporters to cast Justice Alexandre de Moraes as an authoritarian renegade who is intent on censoring political speech in Brazil.
The panel that voted in a virtual session was comprised of five of the full bench鈥檚 11 justices, including de Moraes, who last Friday ordered the platform blocked for refusing to name a local legal representative, as required by law. It will stay suspended until it complies with his orders and pays outstanding fines that as of last week exceeded $3 million, according to his decision.
The platform has clashed with de Moraes over its reluctance to block users, and has alleged that de Moraes wants an in-country legal representative so that Brazilian authorities can exert leverage over the company by having someone to arrest.
De Moraes also set a daily fine of 50,000 reais ($8,900) for people or companies using virtual private networks, or VPNs, to access X. Some legal experts questioned the grounds for that decision and how it would be enforced, including Brazil鈥檚 bar association, which said it would request the Supreme Court review that provision.
But the majority of the panel upheld the VPN fine 鈥� with one justice opposing unless users are shown to be using X to commit crimes.
for X, with tens of millions of users. Its block marked a dramatic between Musk and de Moraes over free speech, far-right accounts and misinformation.
Over the weekend, many X users in Brazil said they and began migrating en masse to alternative platforms, like Bluesky and Threads.
The suspension has also proceeded to set up a showdown between de Moraes and Musk鈥檚 satellite internet provider Starlink, which is refusing to enforce the justice's decision.
鈥淗e violated the constitution of Brazil repeatedly and egregiously, after swearing an oath to protect it,鈥� Musk wrote in the hours before the vote, adding a flurry of insults and accusations in the wake of the panel's vote. On Sunday, Musk announced the creation of an X account to publish the justice鈥檚 sealed decisions that he said would show they violated Brazilian law.
But legal experts have said such claims don't hold water, noting in particular that de Moraes' peers have repeatedly endorsed his rulings 鈥� as they did on Monday. Although his actions are viewed by experts as legal, they have over whether one man has been afforded too much power, or if his rulings should have more transparency.
De Moraes' decision to quickly refer his order for panel approval served to obtain 鈥渃ollective, more institutional support that attempts to depersonalize the decision,鈥� Conrado H眉bner, a constitutional law expert at the University of Sao Paulo, told The Associated Press.
It is standard for a justice to refer such cases to a five-justice panel, H眉bner said. In exceptional cases, the justice also could refer the case to the full bench for review. Had de Moraes done the latter, two justices who have questioned his decisions in the past 鈥� and were appointed by 鈥� would have had the opportunity to object or hinder the vote鈥檚 advance.
X's block already led de Moraes last week to freeze the Brazilian financial assets of Starlink as a means to force it to cover X鈥檚 fines, reasoning that the two companies are part of the same economic group. The company says it has more than 250,000 clients in Brazil.
Legal experts have questioned the legal basis of that move, and Starlink's law firm Veirano has told the AP it has appealed the freeze. It declined to comment further.
In a show of defiance, Starlink informally told the telecommunications regulator Anatel that it will not block X access until its financial accounts are unfrozen, Anatel's press office said in an email to the AP. Starlink didn't respond to a request for comment.
鈥淚f I鈥檓 not mistaken, it was a WhatsApp message that the legal representative of Starlink sent to the president of Anatel, forwarding a message from the company in the United States,鈥� said Arthur Coimbra, a board member of Anatel, on a video call from his office in Brasilia.
That communication doesn鈥檛 hold legal value as conclusive evidence of non-compliance but prompted the telecommunications regulator to conduct inspections on Monday.
Coimbra said Anatel would finish an inspection report by the end of the day and then send it to the Supreme Court. He added that the maximum sanction for a telecom company would be revocation of its license. If Starlink loses its license and continues providing service, it would be committing a crime. Anatel could seize equipment from Starlink鈥檚 ground stations in Brazil that ensure the quality of its internet service, he said.
The ground stations receive and transmit data between satellites and the Earth. When a user accesses the internet via satellite, the data request is sent to the satellite, which then forwards it to the ground station connected to the global internet network.
That means a shutdown of Starlink is likely, although enforcement will be difficult given the company's satellites aren鈥檛 inside national territory, said Luca Belli, coordinator of the Technology and Society Center at the Getulio Vargas Foundation. It is popular in Brazil's
Anatel鈥檚 President Carlos Baigorri told local media GloboNews late Sunday afternoon that he has relayed Starlink鈥檚 decision to Justice de Moraes.
鈥淚t is highly probable there is a political escalation," because Starlink is "explicitly refusing to comply with orders, national laws,鈥� said Belli, who is also a professor at the Getulio Vargas Foundation's law school.
The arguments from Musk, a self-proclaimed 鈥渇ree-speech absolutist," have found fertile ground with Brazil鈥檚 political right, who view de Moraes鈥� actions as political persecution against Bolsonaro's supporters.
On Brazilian orders, X previously has shut down accounts including of lawmakers affiliated with Bolsonaro鈥檚 right-wing party and far-right activists accused of undermining Brazilian democracy. X鈥檚 lawyers in April sent a document to the Supreme Court, saying that since 2019 it had suspended or blocked 226 users.
Bolsonaro and his allies have cheered on Musk for defying de Moraes. Supporters rallied in April with a giant sign reading 鈥淏razil Thanks Elon Musk."
Earlier over the dissemination of defamatory fake news and another probe over possible obstruction, incitement and criminal organization.
Bolsonaro is also the target of a de Moraes probe over whether the former president had a role in inciting an attempted coup to overturn the results of the 2022 election that he lost.
___
S谩 Pessoa reported from Sao Paulo.
David Biller And Gabriela S谩 Pessoa, The Associated Press
